.. _chapter_thewhyofzap:

********************************************************************************
The Why of Zap
********************************************************************************

ZAP happened by surprise. It had always been at the back of my mind that
Something Should Be Done About DelPhi, the program written at Columbia
University in the lab of Barry Honig by Barry, Kim Sharp, Mike Gilson,
Shridhara Shridharan and me. While a very useful program, it was getting
harder and harder to develop, partly because it was written in FORTRAN (not
that there's anything wrong with that), partly because that's just the way
academic code is. We don't know how to program but we want answers and we
want them now.

ZAP really came about because of Andrew Grant. Andy was in the Scheraga lab
struggling, as most of us do, with the nonlinear PB equation. He left to
join AstraZeneca in 1993 but we kept in contact. In '95, he and Barry Pickup
at  the University of Sheffield published a remarkable paper (J. Comp.
Chem.).  They  reported  the hard-sphere volume of a molecule could be
calculated  to  0.1%  accuracy  by  using atom-centered Gaussians. The
correspondence between a discrete and a smooth, continuous function was
nothing  short  of  remarkable. Since the dielectric approach of PB is
essentially volumetric because molecules are low-dielectric and solvent
high, it occurred to us that this was the bedrock on which to build a new PB
approach. That approach became ZAP.

There were several reasons to be excited about the Gaussian based approach.
A smooth-function dielectric mapped onto a grid has few of the numerical
problems plaguing DelPhi - instability with respect to grid placement,
sensitivity to grid spacing. Also it is an interesting alternative physical
model  to  most  PB  implementations. Typically it is assumed that the
dielectric changes from molecular to solvent "discretely," or infinitely
fast. Why? As there was no experimental information on the variation of
dielectric  it  was  the  simplest assumption and also the simplest to
implement. As is often the way with a successful scientific approach, these
early decisions become ossified over time.

Another ossification is the choice of molecular surface as the dielectric
threshold, as first proposed by BH (J. Phys. Chem). It is not a bad choice.
If a water molecule is excluded from some crevice of a molecule that ought
to  be  reflected  in  a  lower dielectric in the crevice: a molecular
surface-delimited volume reflects this where an atomic surface does not.
There was also a numerical issue. When Mike Gilson first applied DelPhi to
proteins (PROTEINS: Vol 17..), the atomic approach would place grid points
randomly in tiny solvent crevices. Moving the protein relative to the grid
shuffled the grid representation of the protein interior leading to large,
unphysical changes in energy. The molecular surface removed these crevices
unless they were large enough to fit a whole water molecule, in which case a
high dielectric assignment was not unreasonable.

In retrospect, however, the molecular surface is a terrible choice! It's
difficult to calculate and unstable with respect to small displacements of
atoms  or to the choice of a radius for water. And there is always the
question of what dielectric should be assigned to the volume that lies
between the molecular and the atomic surfaces.

The Gaussian approach answers several of the physical objections. First and
foremost, the dielectric varies smoothly from interior to exterior. Although
we made no attempt to correlate this variation with empirical evidence,
choosing instead to match our method to DelPhi energies, the variation of
polarizability over a span of about one Angstrom is physically appealing.
Secondly,  we achieve much of the crevice exclusion that the molecular
surface produces. Because the Gaussian functions spread out beyond the hard
sphere radius of each atom, a crevice receives density contributions from
all neighboring atoms, lowering its dielectric to molecular levels. Thirdly,
we do not see water "pops", those large changes in dielectric from small
atomic displacements (or, worse, small changes of the protein placement on
the grid) that occur in active sites. The Gaussian effectively interpolates
between water absence and presence.

An  advantage  to  this  approach  that  we did not anticipate was its
correspondence to DelPhi when applied to proteins. We parameterized the
dielectric  variation  in  ZAP so that it agrees with DelPhi for small
molecules ("we" meaning Christine Kitchen's heroic work for her Ph.D.
thesis).  Given  that the difference between the molecular surface and
Gaussian model will be much larger for proteins with concavities, crevices
and internal water pockets, we wondered how well the two would agree. The
remarkable finding was that ZAP applied to proteins looks like DelPhi with
twice the polarizability: ZAP with internal dielectric set to 2.0 looks like
DelPhi set to 4.0. Why is this useful? Because there is circumstantial and
theoretical evidence that 4.0 is a good dielectric to use with DelPhi for
proteins, but that always left a loose thread in applying the method to
protein-drug interactions - small molecules should have a dielectric of 2.0,
proteins 4.0, but DelPhi only allows you to choose one internal dielectric.
With ZAP it appears you get the best of both worlds. Protein and drug are
set to internal dielectrics of 2.0 and because the protein is a little more
"hydrated" in ZAP, it acts like the dielectric is set to 4.0. Please note
that while 2.0 is the historic value for the inner dielectric, the current
recommended value for the inner dielectric while using ZAP is 1.0.

On the numerical side, every advantage we had hoped for in ZAP came to pass.
As mentioned in the previous section, we saw faster convergence, remarkable
stability  with respect to grid placement and much improved asymptotic
behavior with decreasing grid spacing. We also, for the first time, had
gradients that could be applied in dynamics or minimization.
