.. include:: ../../toolkit-substitutions

.. _shapefit_method:

********************************************************************************
ShapeFit
********************************************************************************

*SHAPEFIT* is a pose prediction method that is built up on the concept that
similar ligands have similar binding modes in a protein active site [Kelley-2015]_. Given a
molecule that is known to bind, and a ligand-protein complex containing a
similar ligand or the binding pose of a similar ligand, *SHAPEFIT* overlays
the docked ligand onto the known bound ligand. The approach used here is
an extension of the molecular- shape-based ligand-alignment algorithm used 
in *ROCS*. Although both are shape-based ligand alignment, unlike *ROCS*, 
*SHAPEFIT* allows for for intra-molecular flexibility of the docked ligand.
*SHAPEFIT* also guards against the docked ligand bumping into the protein,
when using a ligand-protein complex as reference system.

When multiple receptors, or bound ligand references are provided, *SHAPEFIT* 
searches through XRC coordinates of ligands, determines the bound-liagnd
best able to predict the pose of the molecule and then generates both
a pose and the probability that the pose is correct.


.. _shapefit_basic_algorithm:

*SHAPEFIT*'s basic algorithm:

.. _posit_figure:

 1. Given a set of potential complexes or bound-ligands, *SHAPEFIT* chooses
    the appropriate reference system based on the 2D/3D similarity to the
    bound ligand. The best reference, in general, has the highest 2D/3D
    similarity of the input molecule to the chosen bound ligand.

 2. After the complex is chosen, a flexible fitting is performed that
    attempts to maximize the shape and color similarities between 
    the input molecule and the bound ligand while at the same time 
    minimizing the intra-molecular force field on input molecule.

    *SHAPEFIT* seeds the flexible fit by expanding the poses generated by
    the original 3D similarity as described in (1) and then applying
    the shape constraint of the bound ligand.

    As shown in figure :ref:`SHAPEFIT Optimization<posit_figure>`,
    *SHAPEFIT* works by first using the known bound ligand to
    position the input molecule and follows up by using the bound ligand
    as a shape constraint during force field optimization.
    While the input
    molecule is being forced into the shape constraint, the generated pose 
    strain is monitored to avoid generating high strain poses.

 3. The interactions between the generated poses and proteins are utilized 
    to identify clash-free poses while simultaneously selecting the poses 
    with the highest Pose probability.  

Therefore, SHAPEFIT’s optimization attempts to match the molecule being posed
to the ligands' known binding mode without creating undue strain on that molecule.

.. figure:: ../../../_static/docking_images/posit_images_001.png
   :scale: 75
   :align: center
   :alt: *SHAPEFIT* Optimization Technique

   **SHAPEFIT Optimization:**  Starting from an initial alignment, use the
   shape constraint of the bound-ligand to drive a flexible fit while
   simultaneously minimizing intra-molecular force field of the fit molecule

As shown in figure :ref:`SHAPEFIT Cross Docking Results<posit_cross_docking_results>`,
analyzing the Kinase data set used in
[Tuccinardi-2010]_ pose-prediction using SHAPEFIT is
seen to perform remarkably better for similar ligands than standard
docking techniques at higher *TanimotoCombo* values:

.. _posit_cross_docking_results:

.. figure:: ../../../_static/docking_images/cross_docking_results.png
   :scale: 80
   :align: center
   :alt: Cross Docking probability of finding poses within 2.0 |Angstroms|

   **SHAPEFIT Cross Docking Results:** Probability of finding a good pose based on bound-ligand
   fit-ligand *TanimotoCombo* similarity.  Standard docking results
   are essentially the same and follow the same trajectories
   flattening out as they hit their limit of accuracy.  While *SHAPEFIT*
   performs worse at low similarities it continually increases as
   similarity increases.

While *SHAPEFIT* is not a good technique for determining the pose between
known bound-ligands and fit ligands with low similarity, as the
similarity increases, the probability of determining the correct pose
increases rapidly. This is most
likely because as the similarity increases, the active site
similarity also increases.

On Clashes
----------

Unlike the *FRED* and *HYBRID* methods, *SHAPEFIT* is heavily biased
towards the known bound ligand. In some cases this causes the pose
to clash with the protein.  This is especially true if the
*original bound ligand* already clashes with the protein.


.. raw:: latex

      \newpage % hard pagebreak at exactly this position
