﻿.. include:: ../substitutions
.. include:: ../../apps-substitutions

.. _molecular_shape_section:

==================
Shape Theory
==================

What do we mean by shape? The word is often used without consideration
of precise meaning but in this document we shall be very clear as to
the definition of shape. Two entities will have the same shape if
their volumes exactly correspond. The more the volumes differ, the
more the shapes will differ. We will give a precise mathematical
exposition below, but it is worth noting even at this most basic level
shape is defined as a relative quantity, depending on references to
other shapes. In this we differ from approaches that attempt to
provide absolute, canonical, *shapes* by which to categorize
molecules.

What do we mean by *volume*? A volume is any scalar field. This means a
function that has a single number, or *scalar*, value at each point in
space.  The *special case* for the common understanding of volume is a
specific scalar field that has a value of one inside an object and zero
outside. The volume of a scalar field is:

.. math::

   V \mbox{(volume)} = \int f(x,y,z) dv

The volume function, **f**, is also referred to as the *characteristic*
function.  When the characteristic function corresponds to the common
definition of a volume field this integral corresponds to what is commonly
expected by volume.  However, we are not restricted to such simple functions
and can still calculate a **V**. In general the volume of a scalar field is a
*contraction* of the information represented by that characteristic
function.  It is more precisely referred to as the zeroth-order contraction,
or *moment*.  We will discuss other moments and their uses later, but one
immediate observation is that two objects cannot have the same shape if their
volumes are not the same. The converse is obviously not true. Rather, two
objects can have the same volume and not have the same shape. Volume is
typical, therefore, of most contractions of information.

We can now write down a precise definition of shape similarity. Consider the
integral:

.. math::

   S_1 = \int |f(x,y,z) - g(x,y,z)| dV

where **f** and **g** are different characteristic functions. If this
integral is zero then **f** and **g** are actually the same function and
therefore correspond to the same shape. The larger the integral, the
more different the shapes defined by **f** and **g**. It defines a metric
quantity between the two fields **f** and **g**. The word *metric* is
used loosely to mean *shape*, but here we mean the precise mathematical
definition: *i.e.* a distance that is 1) always positive, 2) zero if
and only if two entities are identical and 3) that obeys the triangle
inequality. The triangle inequality states that if entity A is
distance x from entity B and B is distance y from entity C then the
distance between A and C is bounded by **|x-y|** and **|x+y|**. The type
of comparison shown in S\ :sub:`1` is referred to as an L\ :sub:`1`
metric. Another metric is the S\ :sub:`2` metric:

.. math::

   S_2=\sqrt{\int [f(x,y,z)-g(x,y,z)]^2 dV}


Multiplying the terms in the integral out gives:

.. math::

   S_2^2 = \int f(x,y,z)^2dV + \int g(x,y,z)^2dV - 2\int f(x,y,z)g(x,y,z)dV

This is the fundamental equation for shape comparison. We rewrite it as:

.. math::

   S_{f,g} = I_f + I_g - 2O_{f,g}


The *I* terms are the self-volume overlaps of each entity (for our purposes -
molecule), while the *O* term is the overlap between the two functions. They
constitute the three terms we need to compare the shapes of two
fields. The *I* terms are independent of orientation but not *O*. Finding the
orientation that maximizes *O*, and hence minimizes *S_{f,g}*, is equivalent to
finding the best overlay between the two objects (a quantity that has its own,
distinct metric properties). We also note here that the quantity referred to
as a Tanimoto coefficient may be derived by recombining *I*'s and *O* so:

.. math::

   Tanimoto_{f,g} = \frac{O_{f,g}}{I_f+I_g-O_{f,g}} \label{Tanimoto}


Tanimoto coefficients will be familiar to those who use them for bitvector
fingerprint comparison.  An alternative measure is the Tversky coefficient,
also mostly used for similarity between bitvector fingerprints. Similarly to
the Tanimoto coefficient above, we can define a shape Tversky measure. The
base equation for the Tversky coefficient is:

.. math::

   Tversky_{f,g} = \frac{O_{f,g}}{\alpha I_f+\beta I_g} \label{tversky}

Normally, *alpha + beta = 1*, and for our current use, *alpha* is chosen to
be 0.95. Since this introduces an asymmetry, the Tversky calculation depends
on which molecule's self-overlap has the *alpha* pre-factor.
ROCS calculates two Tversky values, one with the query
molecule with *alpha* as the pre-factor and a second with the database
molecule with *alpha* as the pre-factor.  Also, note that since shape is
a field property, instead of a simple scalar like a bitvector, shape Tversky
can be larger than 1.0 since the overlap *O_{f,g}* can be larger than
a molecule's self-overlap, *I_f*.

The OpenEye Shape Toolkit is a set of calculational objects designed to
facilitate the calculation of these field-metric quantities. ROCS is an
application built on top of the Shape toolkit.

.. _gaussians_and_shape:

Shape Characteristics and the Use of Gaussians
==============================================

Molecules are traditionally viewed as a set of fused spheres, sometimes
referred to as the CPK model. The common view of molecular volume is then of a
characteristic function that is one (1) inside at least one sphere and zero
(0) outside. How do we calculate the volume of such a seemingly simple
function?  The volume of a single sphere is *(4pi r^3)/3* but the complication
for two fused spheres is that we have to account for the shared
volume and not count it twice. For more than two atoms, there are triple
intersections that must be added back in if we have removed the three
pairs of intersections.  The general formula for N spheres that explicitly
calculates the volume of every level of overlap and its correct contribution
is:

.. math::

   V = 1 - \int \prod_i^N (1 - f_i)dv

This is easy to write, not so easy to solve because the analytic formulae for
overlaps of increasing order are highly non-trivial (although they have been
derived to arbitrary order). It is fair to say that this has hindered the
development of shape comparison in many ways. Attempts to use analytic
formulae led to very slow programs and approximate methods, for instance using
grids of points that are turned *in* or *out* by each sphere, do not give
smooth gradients required for minimization. Brian Masek (AstraZeneca) was the
first to attempt to optimize overlaps of molecules using the analytic
approach [Masek-1993]_. His program would take several minutes per minimization. In addition
it would often suffer from a common problem when using functions that vary
sharply (such as solid spheres): it would often get stuck in local
minima. Nevertheless, Brian did have encouraging success using this method to
find similarities not obvious from chemical structure.

The conceptual breakthrough in shape comparison came in 1995 in a paper by
Andrew Grant (AstraZeneca) and Barry Pickup (University of Sheffield)
(\ [Grant-1995]_\ , [Grant-1996]_\ , [Grant-1997]_\ ). They showed that if one let
go of the concept of the characteristic function being
binary, and instead use a sum of continuous functions, *i.e.*
a Gaussian, that the solid-sphere volume, could be recovered to high
accuracy (typically ~0.1%). A sphere has one defining parameter,
its radius, whereas a Gaussian has two defining parameters, its prefactor,
*p*, and its width, *w*:

.. math::

   pe^{-wx^2}

Grant and Pickup found that by fixing *p* to 2.7 and setting *w* for
each atom such that the volume integral for each atom agreed with its
solid-sphere volume, they achieved remarkable precision. In addition,
the overlap terms between any two atoms, and hence any higher-order
overlaps, are all Gaussian functions themselves because of the
Gaussian Contraction formula (shown here for one spatial variable):

.. math::

   \int e^{a(x-x_i)^2}e^{b(x-x_i)^2} = \int e^{(a+b)(x-x_i)^2}

*i.e.* two atomic-Gaussians overlap to produce another Gaussian.
Likewise, a three atomic-Gaussian overlap is that of an
overlap-Gaussian with an atomic-Gaussian, hence another Gaussian. The
simplicity of these formulae and the formula for the volume of each
individual Gaussian leads to very efficient algorithms for the
calculation of the volume of a molecule so represented (the OpenEye
method calculates several thousand volumes per second while
calculating intersections up to sixth order).

In addition to simple calculation of molecular volume, which is the
zeroth-order moment of the characteristic function, the ease of
evaluation of intersections allows for accurate calculation of
high-order moments: called the *steric multipoles*. For
instance, if the product formulae for atomic and intersection
Gaussians yields *n* Gaussians, the first order moments are:

.. math::

   M_{1,x} =  \sum_{i=1}^n \int xe^{a_i|(x-x_i)^2+(y-y_i)^2+(z-z_i)^2|}

   M_{1,y} =  \sum_{i=1}^n \int ye^{a_i|(x-x_i)^2+(y-y_i)^2+(z-z_i)^2|}

   M_{1,z} =  \sum_{i=1}^n \int ze^{a_i|(x-x_i)^2+(y-y_i)^2+(z-z_i)^2|}


These integrals are easy to solve and their sum can be set to zero by an
appropriate choice of origin: the center of *mass* for the sum of Gaussians.
Second-order moments are found from integrals of the type:

.. math::

   M_{2,PQ} = \sum_{i=1}^n \int PQe^{a_i|(x-x_i)^2+(y-y_i)^2+(z-z_i)^2|}

where P and Q are chosen from (x,y,z), *e.g.* x\ :sup:`2`, xy etc.

These moments can be thought of as a symmetric 3*3 matrix which we
refer to as the *mass matrix*.  Rotating or translating the molecule
will change the moments and the transform that sets the first-order
moments to zero and diagonalizes the mass-matrix puts the molecule
into its *inertial frame*. By convention we assign the x-axis to the
largest eigenvector of the mass matrix, y-axis to the median
eigenvector, z-axis to the smallest. Note that this orientation is
still not uniquely defined: 180 degree rotations around any axis also
diagonalize the mass-matrix.  The eight (2\ :sup:`3`) possible transforms
that can be generated by combinations of such rotations actually lead
to four unique inertial orientations.

If a molecule is aligned to its inertial frame, all higher-order
steric multipoles become invariant, ignoring certain sign-changes from
the four-fold degeneracy of the inertial frame. As such they, as well
as the second-order moments, are shape *descriptors*. They are still
contractions of the information contained in the characteristic field,
*i.e.* two molecules can have the same steric moments and yet have
different shapes. (Moments are *complete* in that if we calculate
them to infinite order they do exactly define volume but this is
seldom a practical approach!) Nevertheless, they do contain useful
information and can be used as a rapid, approximate, filter for shape
similarity.

The same advantages that allow for the calculation of molecular volume
carry over to the calculation of molecular volume overlap. The overlap
of volumes are Gaussian contractions, easily tabulated and efficiently
retrieved. Andy re-wrote Brian's program and obtained an
order-of-magnitude improvement in performance as well as another
remarkable observation: if the starting orientation of each molecule
is that given from the inertial frame then very few "false" minima are
produced. The smoothness of the Gaussian characteristic function is
enough to overcome the problems with convergence in Brian's program.
The four possible "inertial" starting points were enough to find the
best, global, overlay between two molecules. This observation and the
Gaussian approach are the basis of the OpenEye Shape Toolkit and ROCS
program for rapid shape overlay.

But note, despite the algorithmic advantages, a correlation with
common perception has been lost. Because the pre-factor of each atomic
Gaussian is not unity, the characteristic function does not correspond
to the inside/outside description with which we are most
comfortable. In the Gaussian model all points in space are to some
degree inside and to some degree outside. That is, the Gaussian model
typically shows about 0.1% error with respect to the solid sphere
model due to the fact that is includes a portion of all points in
space inside the volume.

